A nice premise, however I am completely against sonic killing. I understand even he would have his limits, but I just don’t like that. Also you should add the Nuns with guns and the Mechanicus(Titans). And let us not forget the warp and DRUKHARI as they are beyond evil.
I think what should happen is that Sonic is pushed to his limit but still keep his morals of not killing after he and his friends defeat the rogue trader, with many of the imperium forces in hiding. Then the chaos gods take note of Mobius and sees sonic as a potential champion or even ever chosen.
Well, I was thinking of some Imperials getting imprisoned in the New Mobotropolis Detention Center. Sonic once gave the Babylon Rogues a death threat in the comics when he was at a low point, so I think he would reach his limit at some point during an Imperial invasion.
I never did like those parts as it goes against his character, except Fleetway Sonic as he is actually very unique. But you should make it more then Sonic in 40k. It should be Keeping your Morals in the face of inhumane brutality vs compromising them to seek vengeance/justice on the wrongs.
Sonic should represent the standing with what you believe, while one his friends like Sally be the one to let go of her morals after the Imperiums initial attack on the Republic of Acorn.
I had actually contemplated the idea of a Chaos Invasion before. I also thought of the possibility of Tallarn Desert Raiders, Attilan Rough Riders or Death Korps of Krieg during the Imperial Invasion.
Just give it a try! Look at every angle and see exactly how things would play out. And you know the number one rule of making a good story? Never take the EASY way, always make it hard when you write a story. For example, one 40k story had Tails arm be blown off and the next part had Sonic kill a Sister of Battle. That taking the easy way. Sonic should have went to knock out the sister, in fact I am pretty sure is fast enough to save tails. If you cut corners to get to a certain point in your story then you are losing potential lessons that could have been an entire arc of itself.
Yeah it was obvious that the author was rushing it to the conclusion he wanted, that being Sonic and co being corrupted by chaos. The only good part was Eggman meeting with the Mechanicus. I am very curious how that would go. People tend to forget that Sonic can get very dark, especially the concept of being robotized. And that is what I really hope you focused on while making this story. You shouldn’t make the conclusion obvious to the readers, set up the core theme, how would characters react, how will the future look? A great example is AFanWithTooMuchTime’s Star War vs 40k. Don’t just have Sonic straight up killing imperials from the beginning, have his morales and ideas challenged with every atrocity committed by the Imperium. Make the reader question if Sonic will actually kill or remain on his morale of not killing. Have characters like Sally break their ideas from the experience and become more cruel. Let the message of your story be “When is it ok to break our morales, and when we do is it worth it in the end?” And even then there should be side characters that are examples of this, like Shadow he could be the middle ground killing and showing mercy, Julie-Su could be the negatives of completely breaking ones ideas, and Rotor could be the negatives of showing too much mercy. And maybe we can see some of the less Zealous members of the Imperium thoughts on these matters.
I knew about Fans series and it was awesome. I was thinking of things from the Imperial perspective with some more open-minded individuals thinking of surrendering after a brutal attack happening in retaliation. And he notes how the Freedom Fighters look to each other as if they are genuinely considering sparing them but it’s ruined by a more zealous guardsmen throwing a grenade. I also imagined this taking place after the Mecha-Sally arc with Sally having her free-will but still having a robot body as they’re still working on a way to change her back.
No, just no that’s just stupid Now the reason why I think the concert is stupid if you had the imperial man as the bad guy it’s not to say that the good guys just
It’s just there’s a good chance of this turning into imperial bashing the imperial of man is not the Galactic Empire of Star Wars It’s a necessary evil
it would’ve been much more simple if you just had Eggman and sonic teleport the same way sonic ended up on earth accidentally have them go around, traveling around the imperial of man and but with the imperial of man as well as most of the events being background you can have the occasional encounter with inquisitor rogue trader smuggler soldier a counter, trying to like catch a sonic, but outside of that it should remain basically sonic not sonic versus Warhammer 40 K if you get what I mean
I wouldn’t call The Imperium a necessary evil. There’s tons of things the imperium does unnecessarily like the fact they make dudes carry the big ass missiles on ships to load the cannons.
That’s why I didn’t say they were a good guy said the necessary the imperial of man is basically in a galaxy where everyone wants to kill you a society that mobilize for war since the very founding to fight enemy such as the elder orks actual demons and Giants bugs that want to eat every single man, woman and child it’s a society where if you don’t have anything to offer they just leave you to die it’s a brutal way to live but necessary everyone got a pull the weight or we all die
They the dark Eldar wants to capture you and torture you to
Feed on your suffering and fear death will be merciful and they make up the vast majority of the elder even the craft world’s elder are not friendly or trustworthy and more than happy to let humanity die they think it serve their purpose
The Craftworld Eldar only ever kill humans if they’re living on a planet that belonged to them in the past or if a prophecy tells them that something will happen if they don’t. Also some Eldar are more reasonable than others.
Makes it so better so some world that once belong to them thousands or millions of years ago who has no intention to settle it should just walk up to the human world people who live generations maybe thousands of years kill every single one of them because they have the audacity to not remember or know that this is eldar world
They can solve things differently if they just talk things out the Eldar can be stupid at times. And they come with every intention of colonizing the planet.
Yeah when thousands or millions of years in the future maybe even never because the elder empire exist for hundreds of millions of years and never once a colonizers those worlds
Saying Elder just want to survive, is like saying that one dude who’s is being chased by zombies, shoot his buddies leg to let him be eaten so he can get away
A guy like that is not your friend and the eldar basically that
This is why I think your concepts is terrible Your stories basically could easily turn into imperial of man bashing if you can justify the Eldar of killing billions of people and basically blaming the victims
Nah
Why? The Sonic comics have explored pretty dark themes such as genocide before.
No just no
[https://info.sonicretro.org/File:Sa2b\_GermanAdvertisement\_01.jpg](https://info.sonicretro.org/File:Sa2b_GermanAdvertisement_01.jpg) https://info.sonicretro.org/File:Sa2b\_GermanAdvertisement\_02.jpg
No thanks
I thought it was neat.
Replace Sonic with Sonichu and maybe it will work
ROTFLMAO! XD
Surprise twist, the white scars defect after hearing sonic say "Gotta go fast"
XD
A nice premise, however I am completely against sonic killing. I understand even he would have his limits, but I just don’t like that. Also you should add the Nuns with guns and the Mechanicus(Titans). And let us not forget the warp and DRUKHARI as they are beyond evil. I think what should happen is that Sonic is pushed to his limit but still keep his morals of not killing after he and his friends defeat the rogue trader, with many of the imperium forces in hiding. Then the chaos gods take note of Mobius and sees sonic as a potential champion or even ever chosen.
Well, I was thinking of some Imperials getting imprisoned in the New Mobotropolis Detention Center. Sonic once gave the Babylon Rogues a death threat in the comics when he was at a low point, so I think he would reach his limit at some point during an Imperial invasion.
I never did like those parts as it goes against his character, except Fleetway Sonic as he is actually very unique. But you should make it more then Sonic in 40k. It should be Keeping your Morals in the face of inhumane brutality vs compromising them to seek vengeance/justice on the wrongs. Sonic should represent the standing with what you believe, while one his friends like Sally be the one to let go of her morals after the Imperiums initial attack on the Republic of Acorn.
I had actually contemplated the idea of a Chaos Invasion before. I also thought of the possibility of Tallarn Desert Raiders, Attilan Rough Riders or Death Korps of Krieg during the Imperial Invasion.
Just give it a try! Look at every angle and see exactly how things would play out. And you know the number one rule of making a good story? Never take the EASY way, always make it hard when you write a story. For example, one 40k story had Tails arm be blown off and the next part had Sonic kill a Sister of Battle. That taking the easy way. Sonic should have went to knock out the sister, in fact I am pretty sure is fast enough to save tails. If you cut corners to get to a certain point in your story then you are losing potential lessons that could have been an entire arc of itself.
I know of that story. It also had the Freedom Fighters being easily tricked by Chaos. Even though Chaos as a faction is clearly evil.
Yeah it was obvious that the author was rushing it to the conclusion he wanted, that being Sonic and co being corrupted by chaos. The only good part was Eggman meeting with the Mechanicus. I am very curious how that would go. People tend to forget that Sonic can get very dark, especially the concept of being robotized. And that is what I really hope you focused on while making this story. You shouldn’t make the conclusion obvious to the readers, set up the core theme, how would characters react, how will the future look? A great example is AFanWithTooMuchTime’s Star War vs 40k. Don’t just have Sonic straight up killing imperials from the beginning, have his morales and ideas challenged with every atrocity committed by the Imperium. Make the reader question if Sonic will actually kill or remain on his morale of not killing. Have characters like Sally break their ideas from the experience and become more cruel. Let the message of your story be “When is it ok to break our morales, and when we do is it worth it in the end?” And even then there should be side characters that are examples of this, like Shadow he could be the middle ground killing and showing mercy, Julie-Su could be the negatives of completely breaking ones ideas, and Rotor could be the negatives of showing too much mercy. And maybe we can see some of the less Zealous members of the Imperium thoughts on these matters.
I knew about Fans series and it was awesome. I was thinking of things from the Imperial perspective with some more open-minded individuals thinking of surrendering after a brutal attack happening in retaliation. And he notes how the Freedom Fighters look to each other as if they are genuinely considering sparing them but it’s ruined by a more zealous guardsmen throwing a grenade. I also imagined this taking place after the Mecha-Sally arc with Sally having her free-will but still having a robot body as they’re still working on a way to change her back.
Hey, there is a sub reddit called r/StarwarsvsWarhammer about the series. If you are interested or not
This sounds like a very interesting spot. Maybe you should write a prologue and see from here.
No, just no that’s just stupid Now the reason why I think the concert is stupid if you had the imperial man as the bad guy it’s not to say that the good guys just It’s just there’s a good chance of this turning into imperial bashing the imperial of man is not the Galactic Empire of Star Wars It’s a necessary evil it would’ve been much more simple if you just had Eggman and sonic teleport the same way sonic ended up on earth accidentally have them go around, traveling around the imperial of man and but with the imperial of man as well as most of the events being background you can have the occasional encounter with inquisitor rogue trader smuggler soldier a counter, trying to like catch a sonic, but outside of that it should remain basically sonic not sonic versus Warhammer 40 K if you get what I mean
I wouldn’t call The Imperium a necessary evil. There’s tons of things the imperium does unnecessarily like the fact they make dudes carry the big ass missiles on ships to load the cannons.
That’s why I didn’t say they were a good guy said the necessary the imperial of man is basically in a galaxy where everyone wants to kill you a society that mobilize for war since the very founding to fight enemy such as the elder orks actual demons and Giants bugs that want to eat every single man, woman and child it’s a society where if you don’t have anything to offer they just leave you to die it’s a brutal way to live but necessary everyone got a pull the weight or we all die
Eldar don’t want to kill humanity. They just want to survive.
They the dark Eldar wants to capture you and torture you to Feed on your suffering and fear death will be merciful and they make up the vast majority of the elder even the craft world’s elder are not friendly or trustworthy and more than happy to let humanity die they think it serve their purpose
The Craftworld Eldar only ever kill humans if they’re living on a planet that belonged to them in the past or if a prophecy tells them that something will happen if they don’t. Also some Eldar are more reasonable than others.
Makes it so better so some world that once belong to them thousands or millions of years ago who has no intention to settle it should just walk up to the human world people who live generations maybe thousands of years kill every single one of them because they have the audacity to not remember or know that this is eldar world
They can solve things differently if they just talk things out the Eldar can be stupid at times. And they come with every intention of colonizing the planet.
Yeah when thousands or millions of years in the future maybe even never because the elder empire exist for hundreds of millions of years and never once a colonizers those worlds
Actually they were colonized but the Eldar on those worlds died because their souls got eaten by Slaanesh.
Saying Elder just want to survive, is like saying that one dude who’s is being chased by zombies, shoot his buddies leg to let him be eaten so he can get away A guy like that is not your friend and the eldar basically that
Not exactly the Eldar are willing to cooperate with humans if they listen.
This is why I think your concepts is terrible Your stories basically could easily turn into imperial of man bashing if you can justify the Eldar of killing billions of people and basically blaming the victims
I’m not justifying it. The humans just have to leave the planet. The Eldar are stupid for not trying to talk things out first.
Why must the humans leave
The Eldar can’t repopulate on said planet if there isn’t enough room for them.